Cashing in on a Muni Market CollapseJanuary 5th, 2012 by David Waring
Investors may legitimately ask if they may be in a position to benefit from a collapse in the municipal bond market, and if so how this can be done.
In the equity markets, investors who anticipate a collapse in the price of a share could opt for short selling. This involves borrowing the shares from a broker and then buying them at a later date, after the price has gone down, to return them to the broker. This mechanism does not work in the municipal bond market where it is generally not possible to borrow bonds as they are in the hands of mutual funds and individuals and not available for trading.
It is therefore necessary to look for a security that is traded on the stock exchange and is closely related to the fate of municipal bonds.
One could try short selling the securities of corporations involved in insuring the bond market, but only a small proportion of municipal bonds are covered by insurance. The insurers have already seen large falls in the price of their stock (NYSE: AGO is down 30% on the year) and the problems and uncertainties on the municipal bond market are already taken into account in the stock price.
Consider exchange traded funds
There is another way. Investors could try short selling exchange traded funds (ETFs) that track the municipal bond market. ETFs are traded on the stock exchange and can be bought and sold in the same way as other shares. It is therefore possible to short sell an ETF. The ETF tracks the performance of a particular market or index by acquiring a representative sample of securities from that market. Provided that the ETF tracks the municipal bond market widely throughout the US a collapse in the municipal bond market would be reflected in the value of the ETF.
The largest municipal bond ETF is the iShares S&P National AMT-Free Municipal Bond Fund (MUB).
An alternative strategy would be to look at the States where there is the greatest risk of defaults in municipal bonds and to short sell ETFs that track bonds in these States. Currently only the largest states have ETF’s dedicated specifically to their Muni Bonds, however this may change in the future.
Two states where you can employ this strategy now are New York with the iShares S&P New York Municipal ETF (NYF) and California with the SPDR Barclays Capital California Municipal ETF (CXA).
Embarking on a strategy of short selling municipal bond ETFs is a risky investment strategy and should be given very careful consideration. Many commentators and other players such as the credit rating agencies do not agree with the gloomy predictions of Meredith Whitney. Even if those predictions turn out to be true, the Federal government could move to provide additional funding to the States, helping their finances and thwarting the short selling strategy.